Sadly, at the start of summer, a crack appeared in our ceramic smooth surface electric stove. I found the stove on Craigslist 7 years ago and it was a great deal to replace the original coil burner stove that was installed when the house was built. When we remodeled the kitchen two years ago it was one of three appliances we kept (along with oven and refrigerator) as we only replaced the dishwasher for the remodel.
Of course, the crack started out small over the largest burner and gradually got bigger. I googled the issue and found scary stuff like “if you use the cracked burner, your stove could explode”. I don’t know if that’s true, but I didn’t chance it, so we stopped using that burner and only used the other three. Two of the three are tiny and pretty much useless for any medium to large sized pots.
I started researching the possibility of replacing it with a gas stove. Our kitchen does not have a gas line so installing a gas stove would mean hiring someone to run the gas line to the stove. As I did research, I learned more about induction stoves as an option. Although they look similar to the electric smooth surface cooktop we had before, induction stoves work using completely different technology. They do not heat up an element that transfers heat from stove to pot. They use electromagnetism to transfer (induce) energy to the pot itself. That energy heats up the pot to cook the food.
I decided to go to a store that allows you to test both types out: the Sub Zero appliance show room. Sub Zero manufactures cooktops under the Wolf name.
My visit to the store started by calling first to set an appointment. The store layout had an entrance on the first floor with stairs leading you up to the main showroom. The showroom consisted of aisles of cooktops (and other appliances i.e. refrigerators, ovens) on one side with a full working demonstration kitchen on the other side of the floor.
I looked at both gas cooktops and induction cooktops and even combinations of the two. I really liked the option of being able to combine one 24 inch burner with a 12 inch burner into one 36 inch cooktop. You can have the best of both worlds: induction and gas!
After looking at different models and styles (I also loved the cooktops that are even flush with the counter, instead of being set atop the counter with a small lip) I did the water boil test.
I set two small pots of water to boil on both a gas burner and an induction burner at the same time. Once they were both boiling I adjusted heat settings to test the response time. Interestingly, the induction boiled water the fastest and it was just as responsive to temperature adjustments as the gas burner.
The visit to the store was fun but most importantly, pretty useful in making a decision. I appreciated being able to actually use the cooktops to get a feel for the controls.
After the visit, I called plumbers for estimates on running a gas line from the basement to the kitchen. Once I had that price in hand (quoted $400) I set a stove budget. The cost of induction came out to be about the same price as a mid-range gas cooktop + gas line installation. An induction cooktop would not require any additional work, in our case, since our current wiring and space allowed for dropping in another 30 inch electric hardwired cooktop. Once I decided to go with induction, I began researching specific brands and models. [See what I ended up with here]
Speaking of researching models – what did we do before the internet? Consumer Reports? Word of mouth? There’s just so much information out there now!
-J
Can’t wait to hear how you like it! We’ve ordered a 30″ induction cooktop, but it won’t be installed until our reno is almost finished… another 8 weeks away. When the induction was demonstrated to us, he put down a sheet of newspaper over the cooktop, fried bacon and then threw away the splattered newspaper! What??? Who would have ever thought you could cook through a flammable material!?!
Haha! Bacon was the first thing I cooked on my new cooktop! I put down paper towels because we didn’t have any newspaper. I ordered ours in September and it was just installed at the end of October, my thoughts about are coming next week!
Why did we think of that?? I love that idea!
Gloria, what brand of cookware do you use with your cooktop and do you like it?
We actually bought a set from Costco, it’s the Kirkland triple core or something like that, it said it was compatible with induction. It works great. Our Lodge cast iron cookware gets the most use though.
Thanks! I don’t have any cast iron yet. I am hesitant about b/c it is heavy and I am clumsy and I don’t want to crack the cooktop, but I’m interested in trying it out.
We bought an induction range when we moved to our current house because we didn’t have the option of installing gas. We LOVE it!
Me too!
This stovetop is gorgeous! You did good!!!
Those are the Wolf cooktops in the pictures. I’ll include pictures of the one we decided on in the next post!
I love that you found a place to compare the two different types of stoves. I have had this debate with the Mr., as we both love the idea of gas, but I don’t really want to have to install a propane tank on the side of the house.
When it comes time for us to make this decision, I’ll look for one of these places for comparison. Great story!
Love that you were able to compare! Thanks for sharing. We have a countertop stove and will be looking to replace it at some point soon. (It’s the old coil kind and two burners don’t even work anymore!)